Home › News › Puzzle: take one man, not two, because the bigger capture loses

Puzzle: take one man, not two, because the bigger capture loses

Published · By TG, the site operator

Today's puzzle is about free choice between captures. The site follows the WCDF rule that when two jumps are open you may take either one, and you do not have to take the one that removes the most pieces. Captures are compulsory, so Black must jump this turn. The question is which jump.

The position

Squares are named as in the play-by-play list on the game page: column A to H, row 1 to 8. Black's men move toward row 1, where they crown; White's men move toward row 8.

Set the position up on a board and find the jump →

Black has two captures. One takes a single man and one takes two men in a row. Work out which one wins before you open the answer.

Show the solution
  1. A3 × C1! The man jumps B2 and crowns on C1. Crowning ends the turn. White's only legal move is D4 × B6, which takes C5.
  2. C1 × E3. The new king jumps D2 backward and lands on E3. White has one man left, on B6, and two steps to choose from.
  3. If White plays B6 → C7, Black takes it with B8 × D6, and White has no pieces. If White plays B6 → A7, Black moves the king to D4, F4, D2 or F2. The man on A7 can step only to B8, which Black's man still occupies, so White has no legal move and loses.

The greedy jump

The other capture is C5 × E3 × C1. It takes two men, D4 and D2, and it crowns on C1. It looks stronger, because it removes two pieces to one. But it leaves White's man on B2 alive with an open square in front of it, and the position is not won: the check described below found no forced win for Black within three of its turns. The rules page says you may choose any capture, and taking the most men is only a guess.

What to take from it

How we checked it

We wrote a short program that follows the checkers rules in the site's own game worker. Men capture forward only, kings move and capture both ways, captures are compulsory and any capture may be chosen, a jump that can continue must be finished by the same piece, crowning ends the turn, and a side with no legal move loses. The program finds A3 × C1 as the only first move that wins within three of Black's turns; the two-man capture does not. We then replayed the line above and tested every White reply.

Against the computer, play a game on Normal and use Undo to compare the capture you chose with the other one. The rules page covers the free choice between jumps and the rule that a side with no legal move loses, or you can play the computer now.

Sources

Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email [email protected] and it will be corrected.

All checkers news · Play checkers now